Dr. Mom, My Adventures as a Mommy-Scientist

Discussion of my journey from grad school to postdoc to tenure with two kids, a husband, (and a bit of breast cancer) in tow.

Thursday, October 06, 2005

Writing your first paper: Step Two: Where should I submit my paper?

This article is part of a series on writing your first research paper. I am hoping to use this material for a new student handbook when I start my faculty position, so any thoughts, comments, hysterical rejoinders are most welcome.

Where should I submit my paper?

Journals are ranked using something known as an impact factor. The impact factor is the average number of citations that an article in that journal receives. So an impact factor of 10 means that each article in that journal is cited on average 10 times. This number is evaluated by ISI Web of Knowledge each year as part of the Journal Citation Reports. You need a subscription to access it, but most instituations seem to have one. To find out a journal's impact factor, access web of knowledge (or web of science). Then, using the dropdown menu at the top of the page, select Journal Citation Reports and hit go. You can search by journal or topic. The spelling seems to be problematic, so it can be helpful to search by ISSN if possible.

Journals are roughly divided into three catergories: broad impact, trade journals, and specialized. It is very important to target your paper to the appropriate journal. If your aim too high, your paper may be rejected and you will have lost the time taken for review. If your aim too low, you miss the opportunity for exposure. In my career, I initially made the mistake of aiming too high. Do not believe that your article will slip in. Editors are fully aware of the kind of research that is appropriate for their journal. There is nothing more discouraging than a rejection, especially when the comments are things like solid work, but not appropriate for this journal. And you can easily lose 6 months in the review process, exposing you to the possibility of being scooped and making your work less relevant. If you are uncertain, ask a colleague to review the work and give their opinion. This could save a lot of consternation down the road.

The journal to which you submit depends on the amount and quality of your results. Broad impact journals (impact factor > 10) like Science and Nature are generally for research results that are not only high quality but that also contain a “sexy” component. Realize that this is the research that you hear about on the news, or the Tonight Show, or in popular journals like Scientific American. Is your research so exciting that even someone in a totally different field, or the lay person, would want to know about it? This caliber journal likes to report "firsts." For example, using our ice cream analogy, the first time that liquid nitrogen was used to make ice cream (any flavor) it might be reported in this kind of journal.

In addition to exciting research, with broad impact, these journals require a complete story. Frequently, articles here could be published as two or even three separate articles in other journals. So there is an opportunity cost to publishing your research here. You may pass initial review only to be told that an additional year of experiments are required for publication. On a positive note, most of these journals use a streamlined review process and will reject a majority of manuscripts outright, in the first few weeks. So it is not a large risk to throw an article this way if you are unsure. Chances are, though, if you have a Science or Nature paper, you know it.

If your research does not have broad impact, you will need to consider journals in the next category: highly ranked trade journals (Impact Factor 2-10). For example, Advanced Materials, Journal of American Chemical Society, and Biomaterials are some of these journals in my field. This type of journal requires a strong story, but does not require that research appeal to a broad category of scientists. Research should be interesting to anyone working in your area or a tangential field. For example, modifications of the liquid nitrogen ice cream making technique for chunky mixtures might be published in a journal like this. Marine biologists might be interested in the fact that liquid nitrogen can be used to make superior ice cream (science or nature paper), but not in the fact that chunky mixtures require certain stirring patterns (trade journal paper).

The last category of journal is for work that is still important, but only relevant to those working in the same area (impact factor 1-2). There are a number of area specific journals of high quality that are appropriate for this kind of paper. For example, if you have a paper that describes in great detail the temperature profile of ice cream during the liquid nitrogen freezing process, this would be of interest to other liquid nitrogen ice cream makers. However, other scientists are much less likely to read this report.

Once you have decided what kind of paper you have you might want to ask yourself what journals do I frequently pull articles from? This will give you ideas as to where you should submit. You can use the impact factor to help you place those journals into categories and guide your choice for submission.


At 12:30 AM , Blogger science_gal said...

I'm in the process of trying to figure out how to write my first paper. Your advice is really helpful, thanks for doing this.

At 3:27 PM , Blogger Kim said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

At 7:09 PM , Blogger Kim said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

At 5:24 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

At 4:05 AM , Blogger twf said...

I looked up impact factors for the journals I would consider submitting work to. First of all, the impact factors do not seem to be relevant to the perceived quality of the journal. The journals with the highest impact factors (factors around 3) were some I had never heard of. The journal I would consider to be the most prestigious in my field had an impact factor of 0.72. The journal with the highest impact factor that I would even consider publishing in had an impact factor of 0.98.

So what does this say about my field? Narrow? Esoteric? We don't read each other's articles?

At 12:15 PM , Blogger PhD Mom said...

This is a really important point. Impact factors are relative to the field. For example, another faculty member was telling me that in cancer biology anything less than a 15 was considered a bad journal, but in my field, a 3 would be considered high quality. The most important thing is to identify which journals are high quality for your field. Impact factor is one method for identifying relative quality among a group of journal when you are uncertain.

At 12:07 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, I'm female faculty in Spain, your article here reflects very well some of the problems when selecting a journal to publish. If I may add, someone should say something about the "inside" of the publishing process, sometimes referees are just mean and not scientific...

At 7:30 AM , Anonymous Paper Research said...

Many institutions limit access to their online information. Making this information available will be an asset to all.

At 6:37 AM , Anonymous Research Paper Writing said...

After read blog topic's related post now I feel my research is almost completed. happy to see that.Thanks to share this brilliant matter.

At 4:09 AM , Blogger SHARETIPSINFO said...

In future and option traders trade in lot’s so one can earn or loose quite big amount so it’s always advisable to avail future tips from the stock market experts.
We as a stock market trader should remember we are trading in stock market to earn money from share trading not to lose it as it’s our hard earned money so we should trade with due care.

At 4:23 AM , Blogger sharegyan said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

At 2:50 AM , Anonymous SHARETIPSINFO said...

Commodity trading is gaining lot of popularity in India. MCX and NCDEX are most popular commodity exchanges of India. MCX and NCDEX both offers hi tech platform for commodity trading. Commodity trading should have clear picture like how they can earn money from ncdex or mcx trading and for that they need to track various listed commodities and should rely on research rather than speculation.

At 12:13 AM , Blogger Jack Hall said...

You have erased some valuable points about write my paper work. I was looking somewhere to know where I can submit them so here you have provided good ideas of doing it.

At 3:02 AM , Blogger peter anderson said...

This is great information for students. This article is very helpful i really like this blog thanks. I also have some information relevant for Dissertationmasters.net .

At 7:35 AM , Anonymous Coach Training said...

Good stuff. It is interesting to read comments.

At 8:21 AM , Blogger kavin smith said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

At 12:05 PM , Blogger varun ramaprasad said...

So , if i am not even a graduate and want to submit a research paper,can i do that? Which is the journal recommended?

At 11:40 AM , Blogger Marco Fisher said...

Thanks for your good information and tips for paper submission. I will be in touch with your blog for more update information. term papers

At 2:45 AM , Anonymous MCX Tips said...

Crude oil prices went down and are expected to trade further low. Crude is trading at its support in month charts. Crude oil is hitting new lows because of excess supply from OPEC which has increased further output. OPEC wants to put US Shale oil out of the market by keeping their price low where US Shale oil producing companies could incur loses if they will reduce their prices upto OPEC's oil level.
Stock Tips

At 2:30 AM , Blogger BIGPROFITBUZZ said...

Bigprofitbuzz, stock tips, share tips, technical analysis of stocks, share market tips, share, stock STOCK TRADING TIPS INDIAmarket, share trading tips, stock market tips, stock trading tips, stocks, shares, investing, free tips, free stock tips, share market trading, stock market trading, Nse and Bse. BIGPROFITBUZZ TEAM

At 11:24 PM , Blogger hường lê said...

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.

Great work.

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the

efforts you had made for writing this awesome article.
Sign in to Gmail to access to all Gooogle services. Log in to your account or sign up to create a new

gmail sign in

gmail log in

what's gmail?


Tank trouble

happy wheels

Strike Force Heroes

In this game, you start at the cavern men's age, then evolve! There is a total of 5 ages, each with its

units and turrets. Take control of 16 different units and 15 different turrets to defend your base and

destroy your enemy.
age of war

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.

Great work.
happy wheels

strike force heroes

earn to die

Fireboy and Watergirl arrived again to the temple in the forest. 2 players together can help them to find

their way out.
fire boy and water girl

At 2:08 AM , Blogger Alice Denny said...

Welcomes to google terminal from Austin Texas! google snake
Amazing insight you have on this, Happy wheels it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists... Age of war 2 This article always blew me... Earn to die For how many times I have read this.
slither io Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while slitherio it's nice to find a website that details so much big farm

At 4:11 AM , Anonymous Dr. Kate Siner said...

Worth reading this post, it's a very important one. Writing a paper and submitting it into the right place is important. So thanks for showing some accurate ideas to submit writing papers.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

Hit Counter by Digits Who links to my website?